The 7-phase method to design, implement and evaluate care pathways

Article Sidebar

Requires Subscription or Fee PDF (USD 25)
Published: Sep 10, 2012
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5750/ijpcm.v2i3.247
Keywords:
Care pathway care process clinical pathway design development evaluation implementation person-centered care quality

Main Article Content

Kris Vanhaecht
School of Public Health, KU Leuven University of Leuven
Eva Van Gerven
Svin Deneckere
Cathy Lodewijckx
Ingrid Janssen
Ruben van Zelm
Paulo Boto
Rita Mendes
Massimiliano Panella
Eva Biringer
Walter Sermeus

Abstract

Background: Care pathways, also known as clinical pathways, are used all over the world to implement and monitor patient-centered care processes in a transparent way. Care pathways are defined as a complex intervention, but there is a lack of information on how to design care pathways.Method: Based on the experience of the Belgian Dutch Clinical Pathway Network, a 7-phase method to develop, implement, evaluate and continuously follow up a care pathway was designed. An international expert panel of the European Pathway Association validated this method.Findings: The 7-phase method can be useful for in-hospital, primary care and cross boundary projects to improve the quality of healthcare processes. This 7-phase method includes a screening phase, a project management phase, a diagnostic- and objectification phase, a development phase, an implementation phase, an evaluation phase and a continuous follow-up phase.Conclusion: This method can offer support to multidisciplinary teams (re)designing and implementing safe, efficient, effective, person-centered, timely, equitable, continuous and integrated care processes. However, the method is no guarantee to success. The key to success is the collaboration and critical attitude of the entire multidisciplinary team when implementing pathways.Originality: This paper is the first publication defining the detailed steps to design care pathways. The content is based on international experience and discussions within an expert panel. The method can support clinicians and healthcare managers in re-designing their processes of care.

Article Details

Issue
Vol. 2 No. 3 (2012): September
Section
Regular Articles

References

Campbell, H., Hotchkiss, R., Bradshaw, N. & Porteous, M. (1998). Integrated care pathways. British Medical Journal 316, 133-137.

Pearson, S.D., Goulart-Fisher, D. & Lee, T.H. 1995. Critical pathways as a strategy for improving care: problems and potential. Annals of Internal Medicine 123 (12) 941-948.

Vanhaecht, K., Panella, M., Van Zelm, R.T. & Sermeus, W. (2010). An overview on the concept and history of care pathways as complex interventions. International Journal of Care Pathways 14, 117-123.

Every, N. R., Hochman, J., Becker, R., Kopecky, S. & Cannon, C. P. (2000). Critical pathways:a review. Circulation 101 (4) 461-465.

Goldmann, D. (2010). Five puzzle pieces, ten cautionary notes. International Journal of Care Pathways 14, 33-35.

Panella, M., Marchisio, S. & Di Stanislao, F. (2003). Reducing clinical variations with clinical pathways: do pathways work? International Journal for Quality in Health Care 15 (6) 509-521.

Zander, K., Etheredge, M.L. & Bower, K.A. (1987). Nursing Case Management: Blueprints For Transformation. Boston, Massachusetts: New England Medical Center Hospitals.

Barbieri, A., Vanhaecht, K., Van Herck, P., Sermeus, W., Faggiano, F., Marchisio, S. & Panella, M. (2009). Effects of clinical pathways in the joint replacement: a meta-analysis. BMC Medicine 7 (1) 32.

Godderis, L., Vanhaecht, K., Masschelein, R., Sermeus, W. & Veulemans, H. (2004). Prevention pathways: application of the critical path methodology in occupational health services. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine 46 (1) 39-47.

Hindle, D. & Yazbeck, A.M. (2005). Clinical pathways in 17 European Union countries: a purposive survey. Australian Health Review 29 (1) 94-104.

Holden, W.E., Lewinsohn, D.M., Osborne, M.L., Griffin, C., Spencer, A., Duncan, C. & Deffebach, M.E. (2004). Use of a clinical pathway to manage unsuspected radiographic findings. Chest 125 (5) 1753-1760.

Kwan, J. & Sandercock, P. (2004). In-hospital care pathways for stroke. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 18 (4) CD002924.

Loeb, M., Carusone, S.C., Goeree, R., Walter, S.D., Brazil, K., Krueger, P., Simor, A., Moss, L. & Marrie, T. (2006). Effect of a clinical pathway to reduce hospitalizations in nursing home residents with pneumonia: a randomized controlled trial. Journal of the American Medical Association 295 (21) 2503-2510.

Marchisio, S., Vanetti, M., Valsesia, R., Carnevale, L. & Panella, M. (2009). Effect of Introducing a Care Pathway to Standardize Treatment and Nursing of Schizophrenia. Community Mental Health Journal 45, 255-259.

Vanhaecht, K., Bollmann, M., Bower, K., Gallagher, C., Gardini, A., Guezo, J., Jansen, U., Massoud, R., Moody, K., Sermeus, W., Van Zelm, R.T., Whittle, C.L., Yazbeck, A.M., Zander, K. & Panella, M. (2006). Prevalence and use of clinical pathways in 23 countries - an international survey by the European Pathway Association E-P-A.org. Journal of Integrated Care Pathways 10, 28-34.

Zander, K. (2002). Integrated Care Pathways: eleven international trends. Journal of Integrated Care Pathways 6, 101-107.

Bergman, D.A. (1999). Evidence-based guidelines and critical pathways for quality improvement. Pediatrics 103 (1 Supplement E) 225-232.

Healy, W.L., Ayers, M.E., Iorio, R., Patch, D.A., Appleby, D. & Pfeifer, B.A. (1998). Impact of a clinical pathway and implant standardization on total hip arthroplasty: a clinical and economic study of short-term patient outcome. Journal of Arthroplasty 13 (3) 266-276.

Lagoe, R.J. & Aspling, D.L. (1997). Benchmarking and clinical pathway implementation on a multihospital basis. Nursing Economics Journal 15 (3) 131-137.

Zander, K. & McGill, R. (1994). Critical and anticipated recovery paths: only the beginning. Nursing Management 25 (8) 34-37, 40.

Panella, M. & Vanhaecht, K. (2010). Is there still need for confusion about pathways? International Journal of Care Pathways 14, 1-3.

Vanhaecht, K., De Witte, K. & Sermeus, W. (2007). The impact of clinical pathways on the organisation of care processes. Leuven: ACCO.

Loeb, M. B. (2002). Application of the development stages of a cluster randomized trial to a framework for valuating complex health interventions. BMC Health Services Research 2 (1) 13.

Craig, P., Dieppe, P., Macintyre, S., Michie, S., Nazareth, I. & Petticrew, M. (2008). Developing and evaluating complex interventions: the new Medical Research Council guidance. British Medical Journal 337, a1655.

Medical Research Council. (2000). A framework for development and evaluation of RCTs for complex interventions to improve health. Medical Research Council.

Panella, M., Marchisio, S., Barbieri, A. & Di Stanislao F. (2008). A cluster randomized trial to assess the impact of clinical pathways for patients with stroke: rationale and design of the Clinical Pathways for Effective and Appropriate Care Study [NCT00673491]. BMC Health Services Research 8, 223.

Panella, M., Marchisio, S., Gardini, A. & Di Stanislao, F. (2007). A cluster randomized controlled trial of a clinical pathway for hospital treatment of heart failure: study design and population. BMC Health Services Research 7, 179.

Vanhaecht, K., Sermeus, W., Van Zelm, R. T. & Panella, M. (2010). Care Pathways are defined as complex interventions. BMC Medicine 8,[http://www.biomedcentral.com/1741-7015/8/31/COMMENTS/citation].

Vanhaecht, K., Sermeus, W., Peers, J., Decramer, M., Lodewijckx, C., Leigheb, F., Deneckere, S., Panella, M. & EQCP Study Group. (2010). The impact of care pathways for exacerbation of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease: rationale and design of a cluster randomized controlled trial. Trials 11, 111.

Vanhaecht, K., Sermeus, W., Vleugels, A. & Peeters, G. (2002). Ontwikkeling en gebruik van klinische paden (clinical pathways) in de gezondheidszorg. Tijdschrift voor Geneeskunde 58 (23) 1542-1551.

Van Gerven, E., Vanhaecht, K., Deneckere, S., Vleugels, A. & Sermeus, W. (2010). Management challenges in care pathways: conclusions of a qualitative study within 57 healthcare organizations. International Journal of Care Pathways 14 (4) 142-150.

Coffey, R.J., Richards, J.S., Remmert, C.S., LeRoy, S.S., Schoville, R.R. & Baldwin, P.J. (1992). An introduction to critical paths. Quality Management in Health Care 1 (1) 45-54.

Cordell, J. (1995). A guide to developing clinical pathways. Medical Laboratory Observer April Issue, 35-39.

Ferguson, L.E. (1993). Steps to developing a critical pathway. Nursing Administration Quarterly 17 (3) 58-62.

Giffin, M. & Giffin, R.B. (1994). Critical pathways produce tangible results. Health Care Strategic Management 12 (7) 1, 17-23.

Gordon, M. (1995) Steps to pathway development. Journal of Burn Care Rehabilitation 16 (2 Part 2) 197-202.

Harkleroad, A., Schirf, D., Volpe, J., & Holm, M.B. (2000) Critical pathway development: an integrative literature review. American Journal of Occupational Therapy 54 (2) 148-154.

Ibarra, V., Titler, M.G. & Reiter, C.J. (1996). Issues in the development and implementation of clinical pathways. AACN Clinical Issues 7 (3) 436-447.

Reinhart, S.I. (1995). Uncomplicated acute myocardial infarction: a critical path. Cardiovascular Nursing 31 (1) 1-7.

Wieczorek, P. (1995). Developing critical pathways for the operating room. Association of Perioperative Registered Nurses Journal 62 (6) 925-928.

Zander, K. & McGill, R. (1994). Critical and anticipated recovery paths: only the beginning. Nursing Management 25 (8) 34-37.

Deming, W.E. (1982). Out of the crisis. Melborne: Syndicate of the University of Cambridge.

Hindle, D. & Yazbeck, A.M. (2004). Report of a survey of clinical pathways and strategic asset planning in 17 EU countries. EU Health Property Network and the Netherlands Board of Health Policy.

Vanhaecht, K. & Sermeus, W. (2003). The Leuven Clinical Pathway Compass. International Journal of Care Pathways 7, 2-7.

Anderson, N.R. & West, M.A. (1998). Measuring climate for work group innovation: development and validation of the team climate inventory. Journal of Organizational Behavior 19, 235-258.

Oosterhoorn, A.D. (2004). 111 instruments for quality improvement. (In Dutch). Kluwer: Deventer.

Vanhaecht, K., Van Zelm, R.T., Van Gerven, E., Sermeus, W., Bower, K.A., Panella, M. & Deneckere, S. (2011). The 3-blackboard method as concensus development exercise for building care pathways. International Journal of Care Pathways 15, 49-52.

Vanhaecht, K., De Witte, K., Depreitere, R., Van Zelm, R. T., De Bleser, L., Proost, K. & Sermeus, W. (2007). Development and validation of a Care Process Self-Evaluation Tool (CPSET). Health Services Management Research 20, 189-202.

Massoud, R., Askov, K., Reinke, J., Miller Franco, L., Bornstein, T., Knebel, E. & MacAuley, C. (2001). Quality Assurance Project: A modern paradigm for improving healthcare quality. Bethesda: Center for Human Services.

Deneckere, S., Robyns, N., Vanhaecht, K., Euwema, M., Panella, M., Lodewijckx, C., Leigheb, F., Sermeus, W. & EQCP Study Group. (2011). Indicators for follow-up of multidisciplinary teamwork in care processes: results of an international expert panel. Evaluation & the Health Professional. 34 (3) 258-277.

Wensing, M. & Elwyn, G. (2003). Methods for incorporating patients' views in health care. British Medical Journal 326 (7394) 877-879.

Lodewijckx, C., Sermeus, W., Vanhaecht, K., Panella, M., Deneckere, S., Leigheb, F. & Decramer, M. (2009). Inhospital management of COPD exacerbations: a systematic review of the literature with regard to adherence to international guidelines. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 15, 1101-1110.

Degeling, P., Maxwell, S., Kennedy, J. & Coyle, B. (2003). Medicine, management, and modernisation: a "danse macabre"? British Medical Journal 326 (7390) 649-652.

Degeling, P. J., Maxwell, S., Iedema, R. & Hunter, D.J. (2004). Making clinical governance work. British Medical Journal 329 (7467) 679-681.

Farquhar, D. (2000). Use of a critical pathway for the management of community-acquired pneumonia: the CAPITAL Study. Canadian Medical Association Journal 163 (6) 755.

Gendron, K.M., Lai, S.Y., Weinstein, G.S., Chalian, A.A., Husbands, J.M., Wolf, P. F., DiDonato, L. & Weber, R.S. (2002). Clinical care pathway for head and neck cancer: a valuable tool for decreasing resource utilization. Archives of Otolaryngology - Head & Neck Surgery 128 (3) 258-262.

Roberts, C.M., Barnes, S., Lowe, D. & Pearson, M.G. (2003). Evidence for a link between mortality in acute COPD and hospital type and resources. Thorax 58 (11) 947-949.

Spain, D.A., McIlvoy, L.H., Fix, S.E., Carrillo, E.H., Boaz, P.W., Harpring, J.E., Raque, G.H. & Miller, F.B. (1998). Effect of a clinical pathway for severe traumatic brain injury on resource utilization. Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery 45 (1) 101-104.

Evans-Lacko, S., Jarrett, M., McCrone, P. & Thornicroft, G. (2010). Facilitators and barriers to implementing clinical care pathways. BMC Health Services Research 10 (1) 182.

Grol, R. & Buchan, H. (2006). Clinical guidelines: what can we do to increase their use? Medical Journal of Australia 185, (6), 301-302.

Bower, K.A. (2009). Clinical pathways: 12 lessons learned over 25 years of experience. International Journal of Care Pathways 13, 78-81.

Chase, D.M., Lopez, S., Nguyen, C., Pugmire, G.A. & Monk, B.J. (2008). A clinical pathway for postoperative management and early patient discharge: does it work in gynecologic oncology? American Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology 199 (5) 541-547.

Cheney, J., Barber, S., Altamirano, L., Medico, C., Cheney, M., Williams, C., Jackson, M., Yates, P., O'Rourke, P. & Wainwright, C. (2005). A clinical pathway for bronchiolitis is effective in reducing readmission rates. Journal of Pediatrics 147 (5) 622-626.

Dowsey, M.M., Kilgour, M.L., Santamaria, N.M. & Choong, P.F. (1999). Clinical pathways in hip and knee arthroplasty: a prospective randomised controlled study. Medical Journal of Australia 170 (2) 59-62.

Lagoe, R.J. (1998). Basic statistics for clinical pathway evaluation. Nursing Economics 16 (3) 125-131.

Savitz L.A., Kaluzny A.D. & Kelly, D.L. (2000). A life cycle model of continuous clinical process innovation. Journal of Healthcare Management 45 (5) 307-315.

Savitz, L.A. & Kaluzny, A.D. (2000). Assessing the implementation of clinical process innovations: a cross-case comparison. Journal of Healthcare Management 45 (6) 366-379.

Ovretveit, J. (2010). The future of care pathways. International Journal of Care Pathways 14 (2) 76-78.

Vanhaecht, K., Ovretveit, J., Elliott, M.J., Sermeus, W., Ellershaw, J.E., & Panella, M. (2012). Have We Drawn the Wrong Conclusions About the Value of Care Pathways? Is a Cochrane Review Appropriate? Evaluation and the Health Professions 35 (1) 28-42.

Berwick, D.M. (2008). The science of improvement. Journal of the American Medical Association 299 (10) 1182-1184.