Impact of Tracking Trends in Patients’ Hospital Experiences
Keywords:Person-centered medicine, patient-centered care, patient experience, trend, healthcare organization, hospital, quality improvement
AbstractBackground: Capturing patients’ experiences of care and using the results to improve service quality is one of the key approaches to building person-centered care in healthcare organizations. Studies have suggested that systematic gathering of patients’ feedback through surveys may lead to improvements in care experiences across health systems and within organizations. While trends in patient experience have been considered at the national level, there is little evidence of systematic analyses of long-term trends at the local or organizational level.Objective: The purpose of this study was to determine whether an upward trend in patients’ reported positive experiences could be established in organizations that have a long history of surveying their patients.Methods: The study was a 12-year (2004-2015) trend analysis of overall experience scores reported by patients in three English hospital trusts: Oxford University Hospitals, University College London Hospitals and Central Manchester University Hospitals.Results: The analysis could not establish an upward trend in patients’ overall reported experiences of care over the 12 years. Whereas scores for both Oxford University and University College London Hospital Trusts were non-linear and more erratic, scores for Central Manchester University Hospitals Trust showed a downward trend, with no statistically significant year-on-year changes in scores.Discussion: The observation is consistent with the suggestion that healthcare organizations may not be fully using patient experience data to inform quality improvement. The present study also contrasts national level longitudinal studies, which have shown small improvements in patient reported experiences of care.Conclusion: More policy-level actions and effective organizational leadership are required for the goal of promoting person-centered care through care experiences to be fully realized.
Zhao J, Gao S, Wang J, Luix X, Hao Y. (2016): Differentiation between two healthcare concepts: person-centered and patient-centered care. International Journal of Nursing Science, 398 -402.
Engel GL. (1997): The need for a new medical model: a challenge for biomedicine. Science, 196(4286):129e36.
Nash DB, Manfredi MP, Bozarth B, Howell S. (2001): Connecting with the new healthcare consumer: defining your strategy. Maryland: Aspen Publication.
Mezzich JE. (2007): Psychiatry for the Person: Articulating Medicine’s Science and Humanism. World Psychiatry, 6: 65-67, 2007.
Mezzich JE. (2011): Building person-centered medicine through dialogue and partnerships: perspective from the international network for person-centered medicine. International Journal of Person Centered Medicine, 1:10-3.
Mezzich JE, Snaedal J, Van weel C, Botbol M, Salloum I, Van Lerberghe W. (2011): Articulating person-centered medicine and people-centered public health: A report from the Fourth Geneva Conference on Person-centered Medicine. World Medical Journal, 57: 171-174.
Cloninger CR, Salloum IM, Mezzich JE. (2012): The dynamic origins of positive health and well-being. International Journal of Person Centered Medicine, 2: 179-187.
Mezzich JE, Kirisci L, Salloum IM, Trivedi JK, Kar SK, Adams N, Wallcraft J. (2016): Systematic conceptualization of person centered medicine and development and validation of a person-centered care index. International Journal of Person Centered Medicine, 6(4):219-247.
Đorđević V, Braš M, Brajković L (2012): Person-centered medical interview. Croatian Medical Journal, 53:310-3.
Wong ST, Haggerty J. (2013): Measuring patient experiences in primary health care: a review and classification of items and scales used in publicly-available questionnaires. Vancouver, BC: Centre of Health Services and Policy Research, University of British Columbia.
Institute of Medicine. (2001): Crossing the quality chasm: a new health system for the 21st century. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
Ahmed F, Burt J, & Rowland M. (2014): Measuring patient experience: concepts and methods. In The Patient - Patient-Centered Outcomes Research. doi:10.1007/s40271-014-0060-5.
Robert G, Cornwell J. (2013): Rethinking policy approaches to measuring and improving patient experience. Journal of Health Services Research and Policy ;18(2):67–69.
Delnoij D. (2009): Measuring patient experiences in Europe: what can we learn from the experiences in the USA and England? European Journal of Public Health,19(4):354-356.
Davies E, Shaller D, Edgman-Levitan S, Safran DG, Oftedahl G, Sakowski J, & Cleary P. (2008): Evaluating the use of a modified CAHPS survey to support improvements in patient-centred care: lessons from a quality improvement collaborative. Health Expectations: International Journal of Public Participation in Health Care and Health Policy, 11(2):160–176.
Draper M, Cohen P, & Buchan H. (2001): Seeking consumer views: what use are results of hospital patient satisfaction surveys? International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 13(6):463-8.
Gilles RR, Shortell SM, Casalino L, Robinson JC, & Rundall, TG. (2003): How different is California? A comparison of US physician organizations. Health Affairs Millwood, w3.492v1.
DeCourcy A, West E, and Barron D. (2012): The National Adult Inpatient Survey conducted in the English National Health Service from 2002 to 2009: how have the data been used and what do we know as a result? BMC Health Services Research, 12(71), doi:10.1186/1472-6963-12-71.
Reeves R, & West E. (2014): Changes in inpatients experiences of hospital care in England over a twelve-year period: a secondary analysis of national survey data, Journal of Health Services Research and Policy 20(3) 131–7.
Richards N, & Coulter A. (2007): Is the NHS becoming more patient-centred? Trends from the national surveys of NHS patients in England 2002-07. Oxford: Picker Institute Europe.
Young GJ. (2000): Managing organizational transformations: lessons from the Veterans Health Administration, California Management Review, 43:66–82.
Raleigh V, Thompson J, Jabbal J, Graham C, Sizmur S, & Coulter A. (2015): Patients’ experience of using hospital services: an analysis of trends in inpatient surveys in NHS acute trusts in England, 2005-2913, The Kings Fund and Picker Institute.
Haugum M, Danielsen K, Iversen HH, & Bjertnaes O. (2014): The use of data from national and other largescale user experience surveys in local quality work: a systematic review. International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 1-14.
Coulter A, Ziebland S, & Calabrese J. (2014): Collecting data on patient experience is not enough: they must be used to improve care, BMJ, 348: g2225.
Gleeson H, Calderon A, Swami V, Deighton J, Wolpert M, & Edbrooke-Childs J. (2016): Systematic review of approaches to using patient experience data for quality improvement in healthcare settings BMJ Open, 6:e011907. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2016-011907.
Davies E, & Cleary PD. (2005): Hearing the patient’s voice? Factors affecting the use of patient survey data in quality improvement. BMJ Quality and Safety,14:428–432.
Garratt E. (2009): The key findings report for the 2008 inpatient survey, Oxford: Picker Institute Europe.
Schmidtk KA, Poots AJ, Carpio J, Vlaev I, Ngianga-Bakwin K, & Liford RJ. (2016): Considering chance in quality and safety performance measures: an analysis of performance reports by boards in English NHS trusts, BMJ Quality and Safety, 2015–004967. doi:10.1136/bmjqs-2015-004967.
Bates J. (2011): Methods, reasoning and scope: statement of methodology for the overall patient experience scores (statistics), London: Department of Health.
Ha JF, & Longnecker N. (2010): Doctor–patient communication: a review. Oschner Journal, 10:38–43.
Coulter A, Parsons S, & Askham J. (2008): Policy brief: where are the patients in decision-making about their own care? WHO 2008 and WHO on behalf of the European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies, Denmark: World Health Organization.
Longtin Y, Sax H, Leape LL, Sheridan SE, Donaldson L, & Pittet D. (2010): Patient participation: current knowledge and applicability to patient safety. Mayo Clinic Proceedings, 85:53–62.
Davies EA, Materko MM, Charns MP, Seibert MEN, & Cleary PD. (2011): Factors affecting the use of patient survey data for quality improvement in the Veterans Health Administration, BMC Health Services Research,11:334.
Reeves R, & Seccombe I. (2008): Do patient surveys work? The influence of a national survey programme on local quality improvement initiatives, Quality and Safety in Health Care, 17: 437-441.
Brown H, Davidson D, & Ellins J. (2009): Real-time Patient Feedback Project Final Report, Health Services Management Centre and NHS West Midlands.